Launch in new window

Dudley Benson - Pūrerehua

You are here

National's Carl Bates

Our weekly catch-up with National Party MP, Carl Bates, every Tuesday on the Wire.

Regional Council and De-centralising Health NZ w/ National's Stuart Smith: 2 December, 2025

Regional Council and De-centralising Health NZ w/ National's Stuart Smith: 2 December, 2025 Regional Council and De-centralising Health NZ w/ National's Stuart Smith: 2 December, 2025, 12.56 MB
Tue 2 Dec 2025

Recently, the government has announced some major reforms to how regional councils operate, with regional councillors proposed to be replaced by boards made up of city and regional mayors, and potentially even Crown-appointed representatives, called combined territories boards, or CTBs.

As well as this, Health Minister, Simeon Brown, has called for the decentralisation of Health New Zealand, with the expectation that the entity focuses on deliveries closer to the front-line, additionally expecting a plan to do so by the end of the year.

For our weekly catch up with the National Party, News and Editorial Director Joel spoke to MP Stuart Smith about these topics, starting with the regional council.

Social Housing Plan and the government’s decision to ‘pause’ new puberty blocker prescriptions w/ National MP Carl Bates: 25 November 2025

Social Housing Plan and the government’s decision to ‘pause’ new puberty blocker prescriptions w/ National MP Carl Bates: 25 November 2025 Social Housing Plan and the government’s decision to ‘pause’ new puberty blocker prescriptions w/ National MP Carl Bates: 25 November 2025, 21.43 MB
Tue 25 Nov 2025

Housing Minister Chris Bishop and Associate Housing Minister Tama Potaka announced the government’s release of the new social housing investment plan which aims to shift to a “needs-based, data driven approach”.

The new flexible fund includes $41 million dollars in operating funding over the next four years, and the government have stated they expect to support up to 770 social homes and affordable rentals in the initial phase.

As well, Health Minister Simeon Brown last week announced a Cabinet decision to stop new prescriptions for puberty blockers for young people identifying as trans or experiencing gender dysphoria. 

The rule, in effect from 19th of December, is based on recommendations from a UK National Health Service review which determined that the evidence to the benefits or risks of the treatment was “remarkably weak”.
The government is expected to pause new prescriptions until the outcome of a clinical trial being conducted in the UK, expected to be completed in 2031. 

Wire Host Sara spoke with MP Carl Bates about all of these topics, firstly by asking about the flexible fund which will replace the so-called ‘patchwork of programmes’ in place for social housing.

Education & Training Act amendments, FENZ restructuring, and IPSOS survey on government performance w/ National MP Carl Bates: 18 November 2025

Education & Training Act amendments, FENZ restructuring, and IPSOS survey on government performance w/ National MP Carl Bates: 18 November 2025 Education & Training Act amendments, FENZ restructuring, and IPSOS survey on government performance w/ National MP Carl Bates: 18 November 2025, 26 MB
Tue 18 Nov 2025

The Education & Training Act Amendment Bill passed its 3rd reading in Parliament on Tuesday last week, which will see changes to “school objectives” including the removal of the requirement to give effect to Te Tiriti o Waitangi principles.

While Minister for Vocational Education Penny Simmonds says the bill “clarifies expectations” for broad learning outcomes, the bill has been opposed by the National Iwi Chairs forum alongside a number of schools across the motu who have been reaffirming their commitment to tiriti commitments.

Fire & Emergency New Zealand has launched its biggest ever restructure in a 266 page proposal which will cut more than 140 jobs, excluding those on the frontlines.

Amidst firefighter strikes and the growing challenges presented by climate risks, the Professional Firefighters Union has said the changes will undermine the “core work” undertaken by support people within the agency.

Finally, the IPSOS New Zealand survey rating government performance has recorded the lowest public satisfaction since the survey began in 2017.

It found that 63% of kiwi believe New Zealand is on the wrong track to addressing key issues. 

Wire Host Sara spoke with MP Carl Bates about all of these topics, starting with the Education & Training Act amendment bill

Climate Change Response Act changes, the Regulatory Standards Bill, and Auckland CBD homelessness measures w/ National MP Carl Bates: 11 November, 2025

Climate Change Response Act changes, the Regulatory Standards Bill, and Auckland CBD homelessness measures w/ National MP Carl Bates: 11 November, 2025 Climate Change Response Act changes, the Regulatory Standards Bill, and Auckland CBD homelessness measures w/ National MP Carl Bates: 11 November, 2025, 20.87 MB
Tue 11 Nov 2025

Last week, Climate Minister Simon Watts announced numerous changes to New Zealand’s Climate Change Response Act, including removing the requirement for Climate Change Commission advice on emissions reductions plans, and easing requirements around public consultation on government targets.

Last week, the second reading of the Regulatory Standards Bill passed through parliament, despite large public opposition to the bill.

Finally, the central government alongside Auckland Minister Simeon Brown and Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown have been discussing measures to “move on” homeless rough sleepers from the Auckland CBD. 

Wire Host Sara spoke with MP Carl Bates about all of these topics, she started by asking about the government’s motivation for changing the consultation requirements within the Climate Change Response Act

Draft curriculum, Deepfake Harm & Exploitation Bill, and NZ Initiative electoral reform proposals w/ National MP Carl Bates: 4 November, 2025

Draft curriculum, Deepfake Harm & Exploitation Bill, and NZ Initiative electoral reform proposals w/ National MP Carl Bates: 4 November, 2025 Draft curriculum, Deepfake Harm & Exploitation Bill, and NZ Initiative electoral reform proposals w/ National MP Carl Bates: 4 November, 2025, 30.49 MB
Tue 4 Nov 2025

Last week, Education Minister Erica Stanford confirmed the latest additions to draft curriculum changes for English and Maths, with the hope for implementation in 2026.
While she says the changes are not significant to the existing system, teachers have said the draft proposes an entire overhaul and greatly increases workload expectations.

Also, ACT MP Laura McClure has put forward the Deepfake Harm & Exploitation Bill to update legislation around exploitation committed on digital platforms especially with AI.

Finally, after 30 years of MMP, the New Zealand Initiative, a kiwi policy thinktank, has proposed a four year parliamentary term and more MPs for Parliament, among numerous electoral reforms that they think can make New Zealand more effective for representing the population.

Wire Host Sara spoke with MP Carl Bates about all of these topics, starting with the curriculum changes.

Megastrike, PFU strike, and MACA amendment w/ National MP Carl Bates: 21 October, 2025

Megastrike, PFU strike, and MACA amendment w/ National MP Carl Bates: 21 October, 2025 Megastrike, PFU strike, and MACA amendment w/ National MP Carl Bates: 21 October, 2025, 19.43 MB
Tue 21 Oct 2025

Last week, the Professional Firefighters Union went on strike from 12-1pm on Friday, calling for better pay and conditions for firefighters across New Zealand.

This week, we will see a ‘megastrike’ of nurses and teachers which is predicted to potentially be the largest labour action in forty years.

Among their agenda items are Palestine, NCEA changes, AI marking and the curriculum.

Finally, a petition with 20,000 signatures was delivered to Parliament relating to an amendment which will see tightened eligibility for Maaori groups to receive customary title under the Marine and Coastal Area act.
The amendment bill passed its second reading last week. 

Wire Host Sara spoke with National MP Carl Bates about all of these topics, starting with the firefighter union strike

Methane emission reduction targets, Benefit changes for 18 & 19 year olds, and Policing Act amendment w/ National MP Carl Bates: 14 October, 2025

Methane emission reduction targets, Benefit changes for 18 & 19 year olds, and Policing Act amendment w/ National MP Carl Bates: 14 October, 2025 Methane emission reduction targets, Benefit changes for 18 & 19 year olds, and Policing Act amendment w/ National MP Carl Bates: 14 October, 2025, 25.42 MB
Tue 14 Oct 2025

Last week, Police Minister Mark Mitchell announced the Cabinet’s decision to amend the Policing Act, to restore the right for police to collect and use images in public spaces. 

This follows a recent Supreme Court case which ruled that an image of a person taken during a traffic stop could not be used against them in an unrelated crime.

Privacy law specialist Gehan Gunasekara says the revision could extend police powers towards a “surveillance state”.

The government has also announced a change of eligibility for the jobseeker benefit to come into effect from next November — which will see 18 and 19 year olds with parents making more than a combined income of $65,529, no longer able to receive payments. 

In the June 2025 quarter, 12.9% of this country’s 15 to 24 year olds were not in jobs, education or training, and despite claims by Prime Minister Chris Luxon, employers and recruitment agencies have said there aren’t enough roles for those seeking.

Finally, on Sunday the government announced their plan to change methane emissions reduction targets in New Zealand, aiming for between 14 and 24% by 2050, compared to 2017 levels, as opposed to the previous target was between 24 and 47%. 

Agriculture and Trade and Investment Minister Todd McClay says the decision is in alignment with evidence, as well as the practicality for farmers — but the decision goes against the Climate Change Commission recommendations to increase the targets, and has been called a “step back” for our climate targets. 

Wire Host Sara spoke with National MP Carl Bates about all of these topics, starting with the Policing Act amendment. She started by asking about the expected benefits of the change

Electricity Plan, Defence Industry Strategy & Freedom Flotilla activists w/ National MP Carl Bates: 7 October, 2025

Electricity Plan, Defence Industry Strategy & Freedom Flotilla activists w/ National MP Carl Bates: 7 October, 2025 Electricity Plan, Defence Industry Strategy & Freedom Flotilla activists w/ National MP Carl Bates: 7 October, 2025, 17.21 MB
Tue 7 Oct 2025

Finance Minister Nicola Willis and Energy Minister Simon Watts have announced a package of measures designed to improve the affordability of electricity in New Zealand through “new projects” and gas exploration, with little details to offer on timeline or cost. 

Employees & Manufacturers Association have called the announcement “underwhelming”, and the Major Electricity Users' Group says there is no evidence the plan will make a difference to affordability in the next decade. 
 
Defence Minister Judith Collins has announced a Defence Industry Strategy that will see further investment in order to develop advanced tech and lethal weapons for export from New Zealand. 

She says the plan will boost New Zealand’s military strength and support our local weapons and tech industries

As well, last week three New Zealanders were among hundreds of activists detained from the Freedom Flotilla, seeking to get humanitarian aid into Gaza. 

The activists will be deported on Wednesday from Israel to Jordan, but calls have been renewed for the New Zealand government to step up on its commitments to responding to the situation in Gaza. 

Wire Host Sara spoke with National MP Carl Bates about all of these topics, starting with the Electricity Plan

Holidays Act overhaul, Electoral Amendment Bill & NZ not recognising Palestinian statehood w/ National MP Carl Bates: 30 September, 2025

Holidays Act overhaul, Electoral Amendment Bill & NZ not recognising Palestinian statehood w/ National MP Carl Bates: 30 September, 2025 Holidays Act overhaul, Electoral Amendment Bill & NZ not recognising Palestinian statehood w/ National MP Carl Bates: 30 September, 2025, 22.37 MB
Tue 30 Sep 2025

The government has announced their plan to repeal the Holidays Act in an effort to make the application of leave entitlements for workers easier to calculate — an issue which has been estimated to have resulted in more than $2 billion in remediation payments to workers for miscalculated entitlements. 

But critics including from Labour and the Greens say the changes will see some workers lose protections, especially when their hours defer from the traditional employment arrangement.

Submissions on the Electoral Amendment Bill reveal that many New Zealanders believe the changes will disenfranchise voters and negatively impact democratic participation. 

The proposed changes in the bill include removing the ability to enrol on voting day, banning prisoners from voting, and disallowing the provision of food and drink at election booths.

Over the weekend, Foreign Minister Winston Peters’ announced that New Zealand does not officially recognise Palestinian statehood, going against the decisions of countries like Australia, the UK and Canada.

Peters said that, at this stage, such a decision might legitimise Hamas, but that the government will take a ‘when, not if’ approach to the issue.  

Wire Host Sara spoke with National MP Carl Bates about all of these topics, starting with the Holidays Act

Latest GDP figures and RNZ-Reid Research political poll w/ National MP Carl Bates: 23 September, 2025

Latest GDP figures and RNZ-Reid Research political poll w/ National MP Carl Bates: 23 September, 2025 Latest GDP figures and RNZ-Reid Research political poll w/ National MP Carl Bates: 23 September, 2025, 20.57 MB
Tue 23 Sep 2025

The latest GDP figures released on Thursday reveal a drop in GDP in the second quarter, down 0.9%.
Amidst calls for Economic Minister Nicola Willis to resign, stating she is sending New Zealand’s economy in the wrong direction – Willis and Christopher Luxon have reasserted that she is the ‘best person for the job’, and point to international turmoil and the previous government as at fault for economic struggles.

Recent data revealed in the RNZ -Reid Research political poll has indicated higher public support for Labour than National, lower preference for Luxon as Prime Minister over Hipkins, New Zealanders increasingly believing the country is heading in the wrong direction and more people blaming the current government for our financial situation than the previous one.

Wire Host Sara spoke with National MP Carl Bates about his thoughts on this data, starting with the GDP